Small Businesses Are Absorbing Rising Costs. Here’s What It’s Costing Them

The buyer didn’t soften it. Every item on her shelf priced above $10 was coming off. Every supplier, including us, had to come back with something under $10 or lose the shelf space.
I left that meeting with a choice most founders are facing right now. Raise prices and risk the shelf, or eat the cost and rebuild. We rebuilt. We’re redesigning our five best-selling products as entirely new items, with new pack sizes, built to land under $10. Between lost sales, markdowns on old inventory and new packaging, it will cost us close to $2 million. It’s a bet that a lower price point will grow that account enough to earn the money back.
The numbers say the pressure isn’t letting up. Consumer prices rose 3.7% over the past year, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics September CPI report, and energy prices jumped 20%. Fuel oil is up 74%. The Federal Reserve’s October Beige Book found that “higher oil prices permeated all District reports,” and that “consumer-facing firms noted tighter profit margins as price-sensitive customers continue to resist price hikes.”
That last line is the story. Costs are climbing. Customers won’t pay more. Small businesses are stuck in the middle.
Why Aren’t Small Businesses Passing Costs On?
Over the past few weeks, I surveyed 19 founders and CEOs, most of them running food and consumer brands with less than $100 million in revenue. The sample is small and comes from my own network. But the pattern was hard to miss.
Thirteen of the 19 said they had absorbed rising costs and accepted lower margins this year. Only six had raised prices. That one-in-three rate tracks the broader market: a net 31% of small business owners raised prices in September, according to the National Federation of Independent Business. The difference is what everyone else is doing. Twice as many founders in my survey chose to eat the cost as chose to pass it on.
They’re reading their customers correctly. Eleven of the 19 said they see at least some split between customers who keep spending and customers who are pulling back. The Fed found the same divide: more than half of its districts said consumer spending was being driven by high-income households. NIQ’s early look at its 2026 Global Consumer Outlook found that 39% of consumers are trading down on consumer packaged goods brands and 34% are shopping more often at discount stores.
When a third of your shoppers are hunting for a cheaper option, a price increase doesn’t just cost you a sale. It teaches a customer to try someone else.
Where Does The Cost Go Instead?
It goes into the team you didn’t build.
Nine of the 19 founders I surveyed delayed hiring or cut staff this year. Seven delayed a launch or expansion. Six cut or cancelled products. None of that shows up in the CPI. It shows up in job postings that never go live and products that never reach the shelf.
Maddie Hamann, co-founder of PACHA, said that her team “decided to cut back spending to the bare bones to get to break even as quickly as possible,” because “investors are increasingly needing to see a healthy margin and even profitability as a baseline for investment.”
That’s the squeeze from both sides. Customers won’t absorb higher prices, and investors won’t fund losses while founders absorb them.
Is Rebuilding The Product Smarter Than Raising The Price?
For many founders, the answer is to change what they sell rather than what they charge.
Retailers are pushing for it. Shoppers notice a price tag before they notice a pack size, and a buyer who has to defend her shelf against discount stores wants items that clear a psychological threshold. Our forthcoming $10 line is one version of that. Smaller packs, fewer premium add-ons and simpler formulations are others.
It isn’t free. Redesigning a product means new packaging runs, new minimum orders and markdowns on inventory that no longer fits. Small companies feel those one-time costs more than large ones, because they don’t have the volume to spread them out.
It also forces focus. Michelle Pusateri, founder of Nana Joes Granola, said that her company chose “sustainable growth over growth for growth’s sake,” adding that “saying no to the right things can be just as valuable as saying yes. Even if it means you are saying no to expanding more distribution.”
What Should Founders Do Before Costs Climb Again?
The Fed expects more pressure. Firms in several districts said prices will increase further “as existing contracts expire” and they renegotiate fuel hedges and delivery contracts. If you’re a founder, the next round of cost increases is probably already in your contracts. Here’s where to start:
1. Map your price ceilings by channel. Find the number your shoppers won’t cross at each retailer, then design products to land under it. Don’t wait for a buyer to tell you.
2. Read every contract renewal date. Freight, packaging and fuel surcharges reset on a schedule. Renegotiate before they renew, not after the new rate hits your margin.
3. Pick your absorb list and your pass-through list. You can’t eat every cost. Decide which products carry the brand and protect their price, and which can take an increase without losing the customer.
4. Protect cash before growth. If you can’t fund a redesign and a hiring plan at the same time, know which one comes first.
5. Hold your values. Ben Ripple, founder and CEO of Big Tree Farms, warned against cutting the things that made customers choose you. “Don’t risk losing the core audience by watering down the values you bring to bear with product bearing your brand name,” he cautioned.
Small businesses have been absorbing rising costs for months, and the bill is coming due in slower hiring and fewer launches. Founders who redesign around what customers will pay, rather than hoping they’ll pay more, will keep their shelf space when the next contracts reset. Start with your top sellers, find the price your customer won’t cross, and build back from there.


Comments